Connect with us!


Where to Find the Best Pizza in Amherst, OH

Who doesn’t love sausage, pepperoni, or plain cheese pies? Whether you’re throwing a party or just looking for a way to avoid doing the dishes after dinner, you might consider ordering out. If you are looking for some of the best pizza in Amherst, OH, here are a few places where you can find it.


D’Tutanelli’s on Milan Avenue features the best pies in town and even won the 2017 Morning Journal Award to prove it. When you order a slice from here, you can indulge in the deliciousness of dough made fresh from scratch and freshly grated provolone. Their specialty pies are out of this world and include the Mac n’ Cheese pie, Spicy D’iavolo Specialty pie, and the Margherita, made with fresh seasonal basil.
If none of the specialty pies catch your eyes, you can always build your own. The choices here go beyond plain cheese – you can build a pie with red sauce, white sauce, or even BBQ-infused sauce while topping it off with ranch, olive oil, or spicy sauce. The real crowd-pleaser is the crust topper options, including garlic butter, garlic Roma seasoning, romano cheese, or ranch seasoning. You’ll be licking your fingers for hours after you eat!

Honorable Mentions

Jillanos: Another Tasty Choice  

Jillanos on Cooper Foster Park Road serves up passionately made pies perfect for football Sunday or any other day of the week. The Tropical BBQ Chicken pie is a must-try, featuring grilled BBQ chicken breast, pineapple, banana peppers, bacon, and a hint of cinnamon.
Seafood lovers can’t miss the Seafood pie made with homemade lobster cream sauce, spinach, shrimp, crab meat, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. You can also create your own pie, choosing from all sorts of toppings, such as mushrooms, meatballs, Kalamata olives, spinach, tomatoes, Italian sausage, pepperoni, and more.

Discover Even More at Lenoci’s Spaghetti House

Located on Oberlin Avenue, Lenoci’s Spaghetti House is where you can go to get a New York-style pie on the shores of Lake Erie. Options include the Vegetable pie, Carnivore pie, White Garlic pie, or the White Ricotta pie.
You can also try the Special pie – pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers on a delectable east-cost-inspired crust. If you’re just feeding yourself, there are mini pies available, as well as strombolis and calzones if you’re not feeling like a slice.

Devour Deep Dish at East of Chicago

If you’re craving deep-dish crust, you don’t have to go all the way to Chicago. Instead, you can stop by East of Chicago on North Lake Street. The pies here are made with a signature pan crust that’s crispy, light, and airy, reminiscent of the kind you will find throughout Illinois.
Some of the specialties featured here include the Taco pie (with your choice of meat or chicken), the Seven Layer Veggie, the Chicago Melt, and the Deluxe. If you’re not a fan of deep-dish crust, you can also choose from the thin, square, or loaded crust.  
With such a great variety of options for slices and pies, you are sure to find a restaurant that you like the most. After you eat, visit Premier Toyota of Amherst today to check out our collection of new and used vehicles. We will help you pick up your next pie in style.


Where to Find the Best Pizza in Amherst, OH - Premier Toyota of Amherst

Your Matches

Contact Us: